Why Minnesotan's Are Putting On Class 4 Impact-Resistant Shingles

Lisa Willett • April 16, 2025
A black background with the words land of 10,000 lakes storms


I have been in this industry for about a year and a half now, and one thing is for certain: class 4 impact-resistant shingles are the new norm.


If you are unfamiliar with the term “class 4”, I don’t blame you. Roofing is boring, it’s an afterthought for homeowners. It only comes to mind when you start seeing your street filling up with yard signs or a brown spot on the ceiling in your living room from a leak.


Since you’re reading this, you’re more than likely shopping around for a new roof. Calling contractors, scheduling those free inspections, and ultimately receiving estimates. Your eyes stumble across an upgrade option to a “Class 4 Impact-Resistant Shingle”. The thought crosses your mind: “What does this mean?”


Impact resistant shingles are marketed to homeowners to be the most durable shingle on the market. They’re designed to withstand the harshest weather mother nature can provide.


Hail and wind are enemy #1 for your roof. In Minnesota, we are no stranger to these events. According to the National Centers for Environmental Information, Minnesota has had 36 severe storms that have caused over a billion dollars’ worth of damage. 


A red car is parked on the side of the road next to a fallen tree.


The most recent severe storm that rolled through the Twin Cities last month brought 70 mph winds, resulting in downed trees. Xcel Energy, the local energy provider for most of Minnesota reported that 135,000 customers suffered a power outage.


We can't talk about Minnesota's severe storms without talking about May of 2022. According to the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources, May of 2022 had six calendar days with severe weather including hail, tornadoes, and wind.

  

A graph showing a number of different colored bars on a white background.

As you can see, Minnesota is no stranger to severe weather events. In recent years, the number of severe weather events has skyrocketed compared to recent history. Homeowners aren’t the only ones to take notice of this trend of severe weather lately, insurance companies have as well.


The trend of severe weather is pushing insurance companies out of “high-risk” areas. According to the Star Tribune, insurance companies operating in Minnesota have lost money in 6 of the past 7 years. Ultimately as time goes on, you will see insurance companies leaving our area, as well as insurance companies tactically adjusting your policy.


Thankfully Minnesota has made insurance companies discount homeowners policies who install products to protect their homes. Thus, we make it back to the topic at hand, the class 4 Impact Resistant shingle. 


Shingle manufacturers can’t just slap “impact resistant” on their products, the shingles have to be put through testing. The most notable test, which the insurance company uses to give homeowners a discount, is the UL 2218 test.

 

“UL” is short for Underwriters Laboratory. In simple terms, UL tests products, and those tests are standards for numerous purposes. UL 2218 is a test for shingles, to identify what class they fall into.


The actual test itself is quite simple. To replicate hail as much as possible, UL uses a steel ball of different diameters (or classes) and drops them at different heights onto a shingle. There are 4 different-sized steel balls: class 1 is a 1.25in. ball, class 2 is a 1.5in. ball, class 3 is a 1.75in. ball, and finally class 4 is a 2in ball. The shingles are classified as one of the classes if they can withstand that certain-sized ball. It’s important to remember that the steel balls are dropped at different heights to create as much velocity as a real hailstone would have during a severe storm.



There is an outstanding report from the Institute for Business & Home Safety that summarized findings of their own of the UL test. One thing was clear, impact-resistant shingles are better at withstanding hail impacts. 

A graph showing the impact location passing rates of architectural and architectural shingles

As you can see in the graph above, shingles with the impact-resistance stamp put up a better fight than standard shingles. At Twin City Roofing, our shingle of choice is the Malarkey Vista.


The Malarkey Vista is a class 4 impact-resistant shingle, but it's different from other IR shingles. Malarkey utilizes polymer-modified asphalt in their shingles. Polymer

Power washing tan vinyl siding on a house in Minnesota
June 3, 2025
Save money and extend the life of your Minnesota home's siding with 5 simple annual maintenance tips. Whether vinyl, fiber cement, or engineered wood, keep your siding durable and looking great year-round.
A man is working on the roof of a Minnesota house with a hammer.
June 2, 2025
Roof damage happens over time, but catching it early can save you money. Learn the top threats to your asphalt shingle roof and when to call for repairs in Minnesota.
A close up of a roof with a vent on it for a home in the Twin Cities, MN
May 28, 2025
Roof ventilation is often overlooked, but it plays a key role in protecting your Minnesota home's structure, roof lifespan, and indoor air quality. Learn why it matters.
white window framed windows looking out to trees for a home in the Twin Cities
April 14, 2025
Check out the top 3 sustainable window frame options for Twin Cities homeowners in Minnesota. Learn the pros and cons of wood, vinyl, and composite frames in this expert homeowner's guide.
window installation in a Minnesota home
April 14, 2025
Looking for reliable window installation in the Twin Cities? Discover how Minnesota homeowners can benefit from our 5-step process for energy-efficient, sustainable windows.
Drone view of a house in Minneapolis
April 14, 2025
Thinking green isn’t just a trend—it’s transforming home improvement in Minnesota. Discover 3 key reasons why choosing an eco-conscious contractor for your exterior project can make a big difference for your Minnesota home and the environment.
A new Malarkey shingle roof on a home in Minnesota
March 11, 2025
Get your Minnesota home ready for spring! Discover 3 simple roof maintenance tips to repair winter damage and refresh your home’s look this season.
An aerial view of a large building with a green roof
May 28, 2024
As I am putting this together, the wolves are down 3-0. As a young Timberwolves fan, I remember the days where tickets were almost a dollar, seats were empty, and they purposely closed off sections because they couldn't meet demand. Sure it doesn't feel good to be down 3-0, but it is a great start to a bright future. One day I was mindlessly scrolling through social media, and I noticed that the official Timberwolves account posted a picture of the Target Center, as a Naz Reid meme:
Icicles are hanging from the roof of a building
November 9, 2023
Once again, the days are getting shorter, the wind is getting colder, the air is getting crisper, and you still haven’t prepped your home for winter. Before you know it, snow will be billowing over your house, icicles will be hanging from your eaves, and frost will be building on your windows. Don’t panic. Prepping your home for winter may be easier than you think with a little help from your friends at Twin City Roofing (TCR). Here, you’ll attain helpful TCR Tips to spot areas susceptible to damage, learn practical tips to help winterize your home, and gain valuable insights into better understanding the importance of adequate insulation for the performance of your home during Minnesota’s harsh winter season. WARNING SIGNS TO LOOK FOR As the rusty colors of fall begin to change to the white of winter, does your home feel a bit drafty? Does your home show deteriorating door seals, weathered windows, worn-out weatherstripping, and corroded caulking details? If so, your home might be showing warning signs that it’s inadequately prepared for winter. Don’t worry, it’s not too late to make some short-term, inexpensive improvements to prep your home for winter. Indeed, several areas that are prone to winter damage include doors, windows, or outlets located on your exterior walls. To inspect your home for the winter season, check out TCR’s practical tips below. PRACTICAL TCR TIPS TO PREP YOUR HOME FOR WINTER With winter right around the corner, a few practical inspection tips you should consider using revolve around examining drafts, spotting issues on your roofing system, and recognizing condensation possibly forming inside your home. Examine Areas Prone to Drafts · Check for gaps and crack under and around windows and doors · Check for condensation forming on the glass of windows and doors · Feel for cold spots on walls, cupboards, and on the floor Inspect your Roof · Look for “hot spots” on your roof where the frost melts in some areas and remains thick and frosty on adjacent spots Ice Formation · Look for ice crystals or frost forming on the inside of your home in unusual places, such as on the surface wood materials in attic spaces, storage spaces, recessed closets, and the inside of knee-walls · Look for sudden stains in areas that you hadn’t noticed during the rainy season To ensure your home’s safety for winter, remember to check the function of your home’s exterior doors to make sure that everything works properly and there are no signs of warping or excessive gaps. Next, check your home’s window operation status for proper opening, closing, and locking functionality. Lastly, inspect your home’s doors and siding fixtures, such as lights and outlets, for missing parts, holes, or poorly caulked areas. AFTER INSPECTION: SIMPLE WAYS TO PREPARE YOUR HOME FOR WINTER Here are some simple steps that you can take to prepare your home for winter. Seal Window and Doorframe Gaps If your windows are drafty and replacing them completely is unfeasible, simply cover them with plastic wrap that Big Box stores sell annually, which will aid in decreasing both your drafts and heating costs. Consider sealing other gaps in your window and doorframes with spray foam insulation, applying fresh caulk to the outside of these frames, replacing the weatherstripping on your exterior doors and windows, and checking the seal strips in these areas. If you notice gaps near the bottom of outside door, simply use a rolled-up rug to plug the gap or an insulated door sweep to fix this problem. Clear Out Gutters and Downspouts Be sure to inspect and clean your gutters and downspouts for gathering debris that could lead to draining issues. Inspect your Siding and Roofing Systems Check your siding systems for signs of cracks, voids, or missing parts that could lead to additional damage. Next, check your roofing system for missing shingles, adequate ventilation, and updated flashing and caulking details. Don’t forget to check your attic spaces for insulation voids as well. Check your Soffit System Finally, check your soffit system for clogged intake vents, painted-over vents, or worn-out vents. Now that you understand how to adequately prepare your home for winter, have you considered the importance of insulation in your home as a Minnesotan? You might have a general idea of what household insulation is, but why is it important to know specifically as a Minnesotan? These are all great questions that will be answered below. THE IMPORTANCE OF INSULATION IN MINNESOTA Winters in Minnesota are brutal. The extreme cold, snowstorms, ice storms, sleet, and strong winds are ruthless compared to other states that have winter. As a result, the need for insulation is heightened for Minnesotans. Indeed, a few reasons why insulation is so imperative in Minnesota is that it reduces heat loss, helps prevent ice damming, stops moisture buildup on roofs, and reduces energy costs. Reduction of Heat Loss First, installing insulation in your Minnesotan home for winter will reduce heat loss by decelerating the rate of heat flow throughout your home. Simply put, insulation keeps the heat inside your home, preventing it from escaping and being wasted out in the bitter cold. With the reduction of heat loss, sufficient insulation, coupled with adequate eave and roof ventilation, decreases the formation of ice dams by maintaining an even underlying roof surface temperature, which also improves water run-off. Reduction of Moisture Formation  In addition, insulation can stop moisture from building up on your roof by keeping the base of your roof at a higher temperature than the air outside. The result of this procedure is a minimization of the formation of condensation, helping protect your home even more from winter. Reduction of Energy Costs Lastly, insulating your home can reduce your energy costs, as any leaks in your home near your windows, doors, and any additional openings utilizes a significant amount of energy and can lead to an unwanted spike in your utility bills. To avoid these unwanted expenses, simply remember to properly insulate your home and you will be on your way to saving both energy and money. TAKE ACTION AND START PREPARING YOUR HOME FOR WINTER NOW By keeping an eye out for warning signs, implementing the practical winter tips, learning about the ways you can prepare your home for winter, and understanding the importance of insulation in Minnesota, you will be on your way to protecting your home from the harsh conditions in winter. Check out Twin City Roofing’s website to see our successful projects, intriguing advising videos, and personal testimonies from past clients! Don’t wait, start applying these TCR strategies to your home now!
September 11, 2023
Think ahead for your roof—learn what types of damages to be aware of so that you can make the necessary repairs now to prevent roof problems next winter. Here is 10 tips to prepare your home for winter!
More Posts